Searching for the pinnacle of steak sandwich perfection? This recipe delivers an unforgettable culinary experience, featuring perfectly pan-seared ribeye, savory sautéed mushrooms, rich caramelized onions, and a vibrant, zesty horseradish mayonnaise, all nestled within a crusty ciabatta roll. Prepare to savor every mouthwatering bite!
Recently, during a delightful conversation, I was challenged to compile my personal list of the Top 5 ultimate sandwiches. What initially seemed like a straightforward task—as easy as “a piece of cake,” or in true sandwich enthusiast terms, “a piece of ciabatta”—quickly proved to be far more complex than anticipated. My passion for sandwiches runs deep, making the selection process an unexpectedly delightful struggle.
My love affair with sandwiches knows no bounds. From the comforting simplicity of a classic Grilled Cheese to the elegant indulgence of a brunch-ready Croque Madame, or the hearty satisfaction of a New Jersey Sloppy Joe (a unique, saucy ground meat-free delight), a masterfully crafted sandwich always brings a smile to my face, no matter the time of day. The sheer versatility and endless possibilities of fillings and bread combinations make sandwiches a true culinary art form.
Choosing favorites among such a diverse and beloved category is akin to pinpointing my preferred cheeses, wines, or even macaron flavors. You meticulously narrow down your selection, convinced you’ve covered all the bases, only for another irresistible option to pop into your mind—one that you simply cannot bear to exclude. This challenging yet enjoyable process often reveals hidden gems and reaffirms long-held affections.
As I pondered the seemingly impossible task of ranking my beloved sandwiches, one category consistently rose to the top: steak sandwiches. I’m talking about succulent, medium-rare slices of premium beef, generously piled with an array of savory toppings, all embraced by robust, artisan bread. This bread is crucial; it must be capable of absorbing the rich juices from the steak, ensuring every bite is flavorful and moist. A whisper of fresh greens adds a bright contrast, while a perfectly seasoned mayo or aioli provides that essential crowning touch, elevating the entire experience.
This particular steak sandwich recipe, featuring its distinct horseradish mayo, secured a very strong and respectable second place on my ultimate list. (My apologies, magnificent steak. While I adore you, the Croque Madame still reigns supreme in my heart!) It’s a testament to the incredible balance of flavors and textures that make this sandwich truly exceptional and worthy of such a high ranking.
Crafting the Perfect Horseradish Mayo for Your Steak Sandwich
Elevating a simple sandwich to “bistro” status often comes down to one key component: a perfectly crafted flavored mayonnaise. It’s truly remarkable how the addition of a few select herbs, a hint of citrus, or in this case, the bold kick of horseradish, can transform an ordinary sandwich into an extraordinary culinary delight with minimal effort. For our ultimate steak sandwich, a zesty horseradish mayo is not just an accompaniment; it’s a vital flavor bridge that ties all the rich elements together.
To create the classic pairing for this gourmet steak sandwich recipe, I infuse my mayonnaise with a harmonious blend of **prepared horseradish, finely minced garlic, and freshly-ground black pepper.** This seemingly simple combination is incredibly effective, providing a pungent, spicy, and tangy counterpoint to the rich, savory steak and sweet caramelized onions. The garlic adds an aromatic depth, while the pepper offers a subtle warmth, completing a flavor profile that is both invigorating and comforting.
Understanding Prepared Horseradish
In most culinary contexts, particularly in the United States, “prepared horseradish” refers specifically to **grated horseradish root that has been preserved in vinegar and salt, typically sold in jars.** You might also encounter it labeled as “pure” horseradish, which emphasizes its unadulterated nature. It’s crucial to distinguish this from “cream-style horseradish” or “horseradish sauce,” both of which incorporate the horseradish root into a creamy base, often containing ingredients like sour cream or mayonnaise, resulting in a milder flavor and different texture.
When you’re shopping for prepared horseradish to achieve the best flavor for your steak sandwich, always prioritize the **refrigerated varieties.** These are usually found in the dairy aisle, or in specialized refrigerated sections of the produce, seafood, or deli departments of your grocery store. Shelf-stable horseradish, while convenient, often contains a higher concentration of extra fillers, artificial additives, and preservatives, which can significantly dilute its potent, authentic flavor. For a truly vibrant and fiery mayo, the refrigerated option is unequivocally superior.
Always **carefully read the labels** when selecting your prepared horseradish. The ingredient list should ideally be short and straightforward, featuring primarily horseradish root, vinegar, and salt. Occasionally, “natural flavor” might be listed, which is generally acceptable. Reputable brands known for their quality prepared horseradish include Gold’s, Boar’s Head, Ba-Tampte, and my personal favorite, Kelchner’s. Visually, the horseradish in the jar should appear a creamy, off-white color. If it has darkened to a brownish hue, this indicates that the product is old and its pungent flavor has likely diminished, so it’s best to choose a fresher jar.
Tailoring the Spice Level of Your Horseradish Mayo
It’s important to remember that **different brands of prepared horseradish can vary significantly in their heat intensity.** Some brands pack a remarkably spicy punch, capable of clearing your sinuses, while others offer a more balanced profile with noticeable vinegary notes alongside the heat. For this reason, I’ve provided a flexible range for the horseradish quantity in the mayo recipe. This allows you to customize the spice level precisely to your personal preference and accommodate the particular brand of horseradish you’re using. Always start with the lower end of the range and adjust upwards as needed.
Crucially, the full depth of horseradish flavor in the mayo takes time to develop. It requires at least **30 minutes, and ideally even longer if your schedule permits,** for the flavors to properly meld and intensify. When you first combine the ingredients, the mayo might taste surprisingly bland or less potent than you expect. Resist the urge to add more horseradish immediately. Instead, give it adequate time in the refrigerator for the flavors to marry and bloom. After this resting period, taste it again. You’ll find the horseradish’s true character has emerged, and at that point, you can confidently decide if you’d like to incorporate more for an extra kick.
Assembling the Ultimate Gourmet Steak Sandwich
This hearty steak sandwich recipe reaches its peak of perfection when made with succulent, butter-basted Pan-Seared Steak. My personal preference leans towards a well-marbled ribeye, as its rich fat content renders exceptional flavor and tenderness. However, feel free to use your favorite cut of steak; any quality beef will shine in this recipe. During warmer months, this sandwich is also absolutely fantastic with grilled steak, offering a smoky dimension that complements the other ingredients beautifully. The key is to achieve a perfectly cooked, tender, and juicy steak, sliced against the grain for maximum enjoyment.
Just as with my Gourmet Roast Beef Sandwiches, I consistently choose ciabatta rolls as the foundation for my steak sandwiches. The unique texture of ciabatta—its wonderfully crisp crust and airy, open crumb interior—makes it the ideal vessel for holding the juicy sliced steak and its accompanying delicious add-ons. It provides structural integrity without being overly dense, and its subtle flavor perfectly complements, rather than overwhelms, the star ingredients.
For toppings, I draw inspiration from classic steakhouse pairings. I adore a comforting steak dinner served alongside **slow-cooked, sweet caramelized onions and earthy sautéed mushrooms**, and these beloved elements translate flawlessly into an incredible steak sandwich. The deep, rich, and umami flavors they bring are indispensable. To streamline your cooking process, especially if you’re hosting guests or preparing this on a busy weeknight, both the caramelized onions and sautéed mushrooms can be prepared up to a day in advance. Simply gently rewarm them just before assembling your sandwiches to ensure they are at their optimal temperature and flavor.
To balance the profound richness of the steak, onions, and mushrooms, I introduce a layer of bright, peppery **baby arugula** into the sandwiches. Arugula’s distinct, slightly bitter, and peppery notes cut through the richness, adding a refreshing crispness and a vibrant flavor contrast. It also harmonizes wonderfully with the zesty horseradish mayo, creating a dynamic flavor profile. If arugula isn’t to your liking, a blend of fresh spring greens or crisp romaine lettuce would also make excellent substitutes, providing that essential fresh bite.
Confession time: I often prefer these magnificent sandwiches without cheese. (Yes, I, a confessed cheese lover, just admitted to enjoying something *without* cheese! Who have I become?). However, for those who crave that extra layer of gooey indulgence, a slice of melted Swiss cheese or provolone draped over the warm beef would be a fantastic addition, enhancing the sandwich with their mild, nutty, or tangy notes.
Perfect Pairings and Serving Suggestions for Your Steak Sandwich
To fully appreciate the succulence and warmth of the ingredients, it is highly recommended to serve this gourmet steak sandwich recipe immediately after assembly, while the meat is still warm. While these sandwiches are certainly palatable at room temperature, the delightful juiciness of warm beef combined with the meltingly tender onions and mushrooms creates a superior textural and flavor experience that should not be missed. The warmth enhances the aroma and truly brings out the best in every component.
For a truly satisfying meal, my friends and I wholeheartedly agree that a generous cone of crisp shoestring fries makes the perfect accompaniment. Their delicate crunch and salty flavor provide an excellent textural contrast to the rich sandwich. In fact, we always make it a point to prepare extra horseradish mayo specifically for dipping these fries. I can assure you, it’s an utterly heavenly combination that elevates the humble fry to gourmet status! To complete this exceptional meal, pair your steak sandwich with a crisp, cold beverage. As shown in the accompanying photos, my personal favorite is a refreshing Belgian-style wheat beer, such as Allagash White, whose citrusy notes beautifully complement the richness of the steak and the zest of the mayo. This combination makes for an excellent lunch or dinner option for a relaxed weekend, a lively game day gathering, or indeed, any casual entertaining menu where robust flavors are celebrated.
Pin
Ultimate Steak Sandwich with Zesty Horseradish Mayo
Ingredients
- 4 ciabatta rolls (about 6-inches in length) , split in half lengthwise to open
- 2 pan-seared steaks , sliced (about 12-ounces each, 1- to 1-1/2 inch thick)
- 8 ounces sliced cremini mushrooms
- 1 tablespoon unsalted butter
- ½ cup caramelized onions
- ½ cup baby arugula
- kosher salt and freshly-ground black pepper
Horseradish Mayo
- ½ cup mayonnaise
- 1 tablespoon sour cream
- 1 large garlic clove , minced
- 1-2 tablespoons refrigerated prepared horseradish , drained
- kosher salt and freshly-ground black pepper
Instructions
Prep the Sandwiches
- Follow the instructions in my Pan Seared Steak tutorial to cook the steaks to your desired doneness.
- Make the caramelized onions (recipe link in the ingredients list) and sautéed mushrooms – I typically make these while the horseradish mayo (below) is resting.
- For the mushrooms, heat the butter in a nonstick skillet over medium-high heat, until foaming subsides. Add the mushrooms, along with a pinch of kosher salt and pepper. Sauté until the liquid is released and evaporated and the mushrooms are beginning to brown around the edges. Remove from the pan and set aside.
Make the Horseradish Mayo
- In a bowl, whisk together mayonnaise, sour cream, garlic, horseradish, and a pinch or two of salt and pepper. Cover and refrigerate for at least 30 minutes for the flavors to meld. You will not taste the full flavor of the horseradish when you first mix the mayo.
- After 30 minutes, taste the mayo and add additional horseradish to your preferences. Keep chilled until ready to assemble the sandwiches.
Assemble the Sandwiches
- Spread a little bit of the mayo on the bottom of each ciabatta roll. Layer each with a few baby arugula leaves, 1/4 of the sliced steak, sautéed mushrooms, and caramelized onions. If desired, spread a little extra horseradish mayo on the top half of the roll.
- Sandwiches are best served immediately, while the steak is still warm.
Nutrition Estimate
Nutrition information is automatically calculated, so should only be used as an approximation.
Please note that our recipes have been developed using the US Customary measurement system and have not been tested for high altitude/elevation cooking and baking.